The simplest Criegee intermediate
can react very
rapidly with water vapor,
and the reaction kinetics demonstrates
a quadratic rate dependence
on the concentration of
water molecules, which indicates
that two water molecules are
required to react with one Criegee
intermediate. This research
result demystified the reaction
kinetics between Criegee intermediate
and water vapor, and
thereupon has calmed academic
disputes and caught the attention
of international community
in atmospheric chemistry. “Our
result is different from previous
knowledge and views, and I
think this should be made known
to all.” Prof. Jim Jr-Min Lin said
confidently. Prof. Lin’s team has
published this research on Science,
the issue of January, 2015.
The formation of sulfuric acid
in the atmosphere involves oxidation
of sulfur dioxide (SO2)
to sulfur trioxide (SO3). This
process has always been an
important research project because
sulfuric acid, with a very
low vapor pressure, is prone to
transform into liquid particulates
(one of the components of PM
2.5) which heavily affect the atmosphere.
However, the reason
why sulfur dioxide can be rapidly
oxidized into sulfur trioxide still
remains unclear. Since the monitored
SO2 oxidation rate is higher
than the estimated value in the
atmospheric chemistry model,
scientists therefore assume the
existence of other oxidizing reactions.
Some had put forward
the possibility that the strong
oxidant, Criegee intermediate,
played an important role in the
SO2 oxidation process, and an
article published in Nature in
2012 discussed this assumption.
But Prof. Lin holds the view that
these studies had not made one
very basic thing clear: whether
water vapor reacts with Criegee
intermediate. Because the water
vapor content in the atmosphere
is over a million times those of
atmospheric pollutants like SO2,
and if most Criegee intermediates
react with water, there cannot
be considerable amount of
Criegee intermediates to react
with sulfur dioxide.
The breakthrough comes
from a student from the Department
of Chemistry of National
Taiwan University, Wen Chao,
a junior to be a senior. He was
admitted to Prof. Lin’s laboratory
as a training student when
he was a sophomore, and had
successively taken part in the
summer research project of the
Institute of Atomic and Molecular
Sciences, Academia Sinica, and
junior college student research
project of the Ministry of Science
and Technology. Prof. Lin assigned
him the research called
“Whether Criegee Intermediate
Reacts with Water” as his junior
college research project. Wen
Chao had to start his research
from designing the experiment:
the first difficulty of which was
to have water vapor contained
in an apparatus and keep it at
a proper concentration, thus
rendering the laboratory apparatus
appropriate for monitoring
Criegee intermediate. Only this
procedure had taken him much
time. First, in the glass apparatus
there must be windows for
the probe light to go through,
but on which water vapor would
meanwhile absorbed, so water
vapor and the windows should
be appropriately isolated, thus
enabling the apparatus to be
used in conditions of high water
vapor concentration. As a result
they applied nitrogen to isolate
water vapor and the windows.
The next question was how to
keep a stable water vapor concentration.
Since the evaporation
of water is an endothermic process,
if the water is not heated,
it would become colder, and the
pressure of water vapor consequently
becomes lower. Through
multiple experiments, they finally
figure out how to have the
apparatus properly heated and
an appropriate amount of liquid
water evaporated into vapor
but not clogging the apparatus.
Furthermore, the student and
his workmates, Jun-Ting Hsieh,
a sophomore at Stanford University
and Chun-Hung Chang,
a research assistant graduated
from the Department of Physics
at National Tsing Hua University,
had to solve the vibration of
the optical table, which affected
the monitoring, and consistently
improve the detection limit and
lower the concentration of Criegee
intermediate lest high concentration
Criegee intermediate
reacts between themselves or
with other free radicals.
To everyone’s surprise, the
experiment result revealed that
Criegee intermediate can react
very rapidly with water, and the
reaction rate demonstrates a
quadratic dependence on the
concentration of water molecules,
which means that two
water molecules are required to
react with one Criegee intermediate.
This reaction had been reported
based on theoretical calculations
in 2004, but observed
in experiment for the first time.
Prof. Lin then resolved to write
an essay on this breakthrough
and submitted it to Science. Reviewers
at Science were deeply
interested in this breakthrough,
and offered many suggestions
which surpassed the length
of the essay itself. Thus it took
a long time for the team to do
additional experiments and reply.
After some ups and downs,
eventually, the paper, Direct
Kinetic Measurement of the Reaction
of the Simplest Criegee
Intermediate with Water Vapor,
had been published.
Prof. Lin and his team have
published on international journals
eight articles on Criegee
intermediate, from the reaction
kinetics of the simplest Criegee
intermediate to those of the more
complicated. Prof. Lin’s research
team finds that double-methyl
substituted Criegee intermediate
does not react with water (a
substitution effect) or reacts very
slowly with water, but reacts rapidly
with sulfur dioxide, which reveals
that Criegee intermediate
might be a candidate for sulfur
dioxide oxidation. In addition, the
papers also discuss the reaction
types and kinetics of Criegee intermediate
of different structures,
for example, the reaction with
water molecule(s) (monomer or
dimer), the thermal decomposition
of Criegee intermediate, and
the reaction with sulfur dioxide,
etc. One of the biggest challenges
in future research is “how
to synthesize the precursors of
Criegee intermediates of different
substituent groups”.
Prof. Jim Jr-Min Lin switches
from his former research on
basic molecular beam to the research
on free radicals and has
established his moderate reputation
in atmospheric chemistry. “In
the past, the story of how Criegee
intermediate reacts was enveloped
in mystery, but now half
of it has been made clear and
the other half remains to be further
explored,” Prof. Lin says. To
Prof. Lin, Criegee intermediate
is a new interesting free radical
in atmospheric chemistry, and
finally a good approach which
can synthesize it efficiently, has
come out for close investigations.
No matter whether it can
be put into practical use, its reactivity
and molecular structure
are special enough to deserve
careful study, and the research
results would probably find their
place in textbooks in the future.
______________________________
References
1. Wen Chao, Jun-Ting Hsieh,
Chun-Hung Chang, Jim Jr-Min
Lin. Direct kinetic measurement
of the reaction of the simplest
Criegee intermediate with water
vapor. Science. 2015 Feb 13;
347(6223): 751-4. DOI: 10.1126/
science.1261549.
2. The written record of the interview
of Prof. Jim Jr-Min Lin on April
18th, 2016.
3. Jim Jr-Min Lin, Natural Sciences
Newsletter, MOST, Vol. 28, Issue 1,
20-24 (2016).
4. Jim Jr-Min Lin, Scientific American,
Issue 157, March, 32-36 (2015).
5. Newsletter from Academia Sinica,
Jan. 6, 2016.
Professor Jim Jr-Min Lin
Institute of Atomic and Molecular
Sciences, Academia Sinica
Department of Chemistry, National
Taiwan University
jimlin@gate.sinica.edu.tw
Pictures
The above figures are the Criegee intermediate experiment apparatuses
The above figures are the Criegee intermediate experiment apparatuses